• Saledovil@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    1 day ago

    Decades of NATO higher-ups saying that expanding towards Russia will cause war with Russia,

    Nations can join whichever alliance they wish, assuming said alliance lets them. What you’re describing here is a condemnation of Russian imperialism, not pushing for war.

    refusing Russia’s membership in NATO

    Russia never applied for NATO membership, there was nothing to refuse.

    and admitting that the war was preventable by Ukraine not pushing to join NATO

    By the same logic, world war 2 could have been prevented by just giving the Nazis whatever they want.

    Sure, that does make NATO more cautious, but NATO has still been targeting civilians, has been carrying out strikes at nuclear power plants, has been committing war crimes against Russia, all without Russia using nukes

    That’s not true. Russia has been doing those things to Ukraine constantly throughout the Ukraine war, though.

    Considering that Russia has been beating NATO in this conflict, it seems that the only myths that got broken were of NATO’s capabilities against near-peers.

    NATO isn’t a belligerent in this war. Your statement is nonsense.

    • Tomorrow_Farewell@lemmy.mlBanned from community
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      1 day ago

      Nations can join whichever alliance they wish

      Here, you claim that it was okay to join, for example, the German Axis.

      What you’re describing here is a condemnation of Russian imperialism, not pushing for war.

      Haha. “Us breaking these promises to Russia will cause Russia to go to war with us”, “if we didn’t make Ukraine join NATO, there wouldn’t be the war”. Really not pushing for war, yeah.

      Also, cute how you talk about “Russian imperialism” while also supporting the gang of invaders of Iraq and Afghanistan (and more). Going to remind you that NATO is the most prolific invader in the world and is the primary force for imperialism in the world.

      Russia never applied for NATO membership, there was nothing to refuse.

      Formally? Sure. But NATO did let Russian leadership know that that wouldn’t happen during talks.

      Either way, Russia joining NATO would have been bad for the rest of the world due to what NATO is - an imperialist alliance that acts to colonially subjugate the Global South.

      By the same logic, world war 2 could have been prevented by just giving the Nazis whatever they want.

      Pfft. You are the one claiming that Russia should have given the nazis whatever they wanted instead of taking action against them. You are the one that says that, for example, joining the German Axis was not an act of aggression and that nobody should have taken action against that.

      That’s not true.

      Ukraine: bombs buses with children, school dormitories, nuclear power plants, brazenly does things like operation SpiderWeb which perfidiously use civilians to carry out military action
      You: none of that happened.

      NATO isn’t a belligerent in this war.

      This is just laughable, especially considering the admittance that this war was completely preventable on NATO’s side.


      Also, it’s weird how much you want to whitewash the most prolific invader in the world.